- Black Star Rising - http://rising.blackstar.com -
The Art of Giving Constructive Criticism
Posted By David Saxe On October 25, 2011 @ 7:00 am In Art of Photography | 7 Comments
I have a very thin skin. I don’t take criticism well, personally or professionally. Over the years though, as a photographer, I have learned to deal with it.
When you live in a world where you are constantly being judged by your work, you cannot expect that everyone will like what you do. Sometimes criticism can be beneficial, helping you understand yourself and your work from another’s point-of-view.
Negative criticism is everywhere, and the Internet is crawling with it. “Your work sucks,” “Boring,” and “I don’t relate to it,” are all examples of absolute statements that do not invite a response and are not intended to be constructive. They are intended merely as put downs, and probably have less to do with your work and more to do with the ego of the critic.
In most cases these statements do not even address what part of your work is displeasing. The simple truth is that these people are not interested in viewing your work as much as dismissing it.
There’s a Reason It’s Called Constructive Criticism
When someone asks, “What you are trying to say?” or says, “I don’t see the relationship between your images,” or “It’s interesting, but … ,” they invite interaction. The critic is puzzled, curious or ignorant of what you are doing but still is leaving room for dialogue. It is not a closed-end statement.
Often a response on your part is all that is necessary to explain and clear things up. That is what communication is all about.
In some cases people may not like your work and tell you why. There is nothing wrong with that, and it can be a valuable learning experience. Actually, I like such comments the best because they tell you something you may not already know. People can look at the same image and have different opinions.
If someone doesn’t like my photographs it is interesting to me to know why. I may not agree, but I have a devilish curiosity how another set of eyes views my work.
Four Rules for Critics
Every now and then you may be a critic. Here are a few suggestions:
The most important thing to remember is this: Not everybody is going to like your work. I often go to galleries to see exhibits that I hate, and wonder why that particular artist was selected. Obviously, the curator of the exhibit would not agree.
I look at winners in online exhibits and prefer an honorable mention to the grand-prize winner. I don’t like Picasso, and think Matisse was a much better painter.
That’s my opinion. Of course, it’s all personal. Opinions always are.
Article printed from Black Star Rising: http://rising.blackstar.com
URL to article: http://rising.blackstar.com/the-art-of-giving-constructive-criticism.html
URLs in this post:
 Tweet: https://twitter.com/share
Copyright © 2010 Black Star Rising. All rights reserved.