Can Taking Photographs in Public Be a Crime?

Scott Baradell edits and contributes to Black Star Rising. A former newspaper journalist and executive for Belo Corp., Scott is an accomplished brand strategist who leads the Idea Grove agency. He writes the Media Orchard blog and manages the Spin Thicket and Dirt 100 Web sites. He has nearly two decades of experience working closely with professional photographers, both as a journalist and as a corporate photography buyer. in Photography Law on February 1st, 2007

A Morristown, N.J., court will decide whether to dismiss an indictment of a man and his girlfriend who were arrested for taking photographs of women’s buttocks in public places, such as parades and fairs.

Morris County’s Daily Record has rightly condemned the indictment:

The key factor here is that the women were photographed in public … This is not a case of people using cell phone cameras to photograph people in a quasi-private place such as a restroom or a locker room…

The defendants’ peculiar habit should not be the concern of the court. The defendants used no trickery. They simply took photos of people as they appeared in public. That’s no crime.

This case goes to fundamental First Amendment issues, and should have never been brought to court.

Share/Save/Bookmark

Leave a Reply